Post by Tout-Perd on Dec 8, 2009 17:31:27 GMT -5
Considering that about a third of them are "YOU SUCK!" prizes, it's not about ego stroking. It's about informing people, and getting in touch with the zeitgeist of the Exodus. It's kinda like how the character popularity polls ran.
Nice to place up top, but mostly just to give you info on what you can do to improve.
Lee's review:
THE PEOPLE'S CHOICE AWARDS
Friendliest Member: Keep.
Funniest Member: Keep.
Happiest Member: Keep.
Coolest Member: Keep.
Smartest Member: Keep.
Wisest Member: Keep.
Most Dedicated Member: Keep.
Most Creative Member: Keep.
Best Artist: Keep.
Best Writer: Neccessary? We've got best Fic and Best RPer. Maybe lose this? Who knows. This is still valid.
Handsomest Member: See below.
Loveliest Member: Ehhh... Last time fizzled for these two. I wouldn't miss 'em.
Best Role Model: Keep.
Most Improved Member: Keep.
Most Missed Member: Keep.
Best Couple: Eh, we could lose this. Not much inter-member flirtation on here as of late.
Best Two-Minute Member: KEEP.
Biggest Penis: KEEP.
THE RAZZIES
Most Annoying Member: Keep.
Grumpiest Member: Keep.
Most Depressing Member: Keep.
Strangest Member: Keep.
Least Dedicated Member: Eh, lose maybe? Kinda runs with the rest of the pack down there. Not too terrible, but I wouldn't miss it.
Biggest Procrastinator: Keep.
Most Impatient Member: Keep.
Worst Role Model: Keep.
Most Run-Down Member: Keep.
Biggest Drama Magnet: Keep.
Most Infamous Member: Kinda redundant with the rest of the category, no?
Most Likely to Die an Untimely Death: We can lose this. This was just between Prime and Rupert last year, nothing will change this this time.
Scariest Member: Keep?
THE PULITZERS
Best Post: Keep.
Best Topic: Keep.
Best Board: Keep.
Best Fic: Keep.
Best Image: Keep.
Best Avatar: Keep.
Best Signature: Keep.
Best Alternate Name: Keep, I guess. Not that important.
Best Skin: Keep.
Best Fad: Get rid of this one.
Best Posting Game: Keep.
Most House Spirit: We may want to lose this category. The Houses, despite attempts at revival, haven't been sparking.
Best Wiki Article: Do we need this? The wiki this year has been almost entirely gruntwork, IIRC.
Best Event: Keep.
Best New Board Concept: Keep.
Best Spambot: Keep.
Best Post Racer: Keep.
Worst Contest: Keep.
THE OSCARS
Best Recent RP: Keep.
Best Overall RP: Keep.
Best Plot Twist: Keep.
Worst RP: I want to see what comes up in the absense of something totally wretched. Shrinking, with the delay coaster? Ulima, with the pissing contests? Chords, because it isn't finished? RXing for flopping on the premise?
Best Storyteller: Keep.
Best Recent RP Character: Gotta stay.
Best Overall RP Character: Gotta stay.
Best Characterizer: Might wanna consider losing this? Or at least, make sure it's clearly defined.
Best Personality: Keep.
Best History: Keep.
Best Powerset: Keep, I suppose.
Best PRP Tactician: Ditch this.
Best Recent RPer: Keep. Good to let newbies know their appreciated, and between Cendra and Shadow and such, we've got a competition this year.
Best Overall RPer: Eh, keep, I guess.
Most Improved RPer: Good category. Lets us highlight somebody who has worked hard at improving.
Best RP Couple: New one. Stays.
Best RP Post: New one. Stays.
Best Fight: New one. Stays.
THE NOBELS
Random Just-for-the-Hell-of-Nominating Award: Staple. Has to stay.
Lifetime Achievement Award: This, actually, can go, IMO. Lifetime Achievement is something either multiple people should get, or none.
Finally, don't forget the suggestion of "Most Twistless RP". I want to see what we have that got considered standard, y'know?
Nice to place up top, but mostly just to give you info on what you can do to improve.
Lee's review:
THE PEOPLE'S CHOICE AWARDS
Friendliest Member: Keep.
Funniest Member: Keep.
Happiest Member: Keep.
Coolest Member: Keep.
Smartest Member: Keep.
Wisest Member: Keep.
Most Dedicated Member: Keep.
Most Creative Member: Keep.
Best Artist: Keep.
Best Writer: Neccessary? We've got best Fic and Best RPer. Maybe lose this? Who knows. This is still valid.
Handsomest Member: See below.
Loveliest Member: Ehhh... Last time fizzled for these two. I wouldn't miss 'em.
Best Role Model: Keep.
Most Improved Member: Keep.
Most Missed Member: Keep.
Best Couple: Eh, we could lose this. Not much inter-member flirtation on here as of late.
Best Two-Minute Member: KEEP.
Biggest Penis: KEEP.
THE RAZZIES
Most Annoying Member: Keep.
Grumpiest Member: Keep.
Most Depressing Member: Keep.
Strangest Member: Keep.
Least Dedicated Member: Eh, lose maybe? Kinda runs with the rest of the pack down there. Not too terrible, but I wouldn't miss it.
Biggest Procrastinator: Keep.
Most Impatient Member: Keep.
Worst Role Model: Keep.
Most Run-Down Member: Keep.
Biggest Drama Magnet: Keep.
Most Infamous Member: Kinda redundant with the rest of the category, no?
Most Likely to Die an Untimely Death: We can lose this. This was just between Prime and Rupert last year, nothing will change this this time.
Scariest Member: Keep?
THE PULITZERS
Best Post: Keep.
Best Topic: Keep.
Best Board: Keep.
Best Fic: Keep.
Best Image: Keep.
Best Avatar: Keep.
Best Signature: Keep.
Best Alternate Name: Keep, I guess. Not that important.
Best Skin: Keep.
Best Fad: Get rid of this one.
Best Posting Game: Keep.
Most House Spirit: We may want to lose this category. The Houses, despite attempts at revival, haven't been sparking.
Best Wiki Article: Do we need this? The wiki this year has been almost entirely gruntwork, IIRC.
Best Event: Keep.
Best New Board Concept: Keep.
Best Spambot: Keep.
Best Post Racer: Keep.
Worst Contest: Keep.
THE OSCARS
Best Recent RP: Keep.
Best Overall RP: Keep.
Best Plot Twist: Keep.
Worst RP: I want to see what comes up in the absense of something totally wretched. Shrinking, with the delay coaster? Ulima, with the pissing contests? Chords, because it isn't finished? RXing for flopping on the premise?
Best Storyteller: Keep.
Best Recent RP Character: Gotta stay.
Best Overall RP Character: Gotta stay.
Best Characterizer: Might wanna consider losing this? Or at least, make sure it's clearly defined.
Best Personality: Keep.
Best History: Keep.
Best Powerset: Keep, I suppose.
Best PRP Tactician: Ditch this.
Best Recent RPer: Keep. Good to let newbies know their appreciated, and between Cendra and Shadow and such, we've got a competition this year.
Best Overall RPer: Eh, keep, I guess.
Most Improved RPer: Good category. Lets us highlight somebody who has worked hard at improving.
Best RP Couple: New one. Stays.
Best RP Post: New one. Stays.
Best Fight: New one. Stays.
THE NOBELS
Random Just-for-the-Hell-of-Nominating Award: Staple. Has to stay.
Lifetime Achievement Award: This, actually, can go, IMO. Lifetime Achievement is something either multiple people should get, or none.
Finally, don't forget the suggestion of "Most Twistless RP". I want to see what we have that got considered standard, y'know?